NYC Painters - Best New York City Interior Painters

Interior Painting & High-End Custom Decorative Painting Services for New York City

(212) 658-1055

Whether you require the painting and decorating of a home, office, store, or even a church, NYC Painters is the perfect choice. We will work around your needs and your times, causing minimum disruption to your home life. We will treat your timetable as a fixed deadline – not just a guideline!

Our success is based on combining experienced, fully qualified residential and commercial decorators and painters, rigorous quality control and flexible hours of working. We use eco-paints with no smell if that is what you need. According to our clients we are one of the best painting and decorating companies in NYC.

We are licensed & fully insured.

The History of Paint Colors in New York City Brownstones

The History of Paint Colors in New York City Brownstones

Walk down a brownstone block in Harlem or the Upper West Side on a clear afternoon and the first thing you notice isn't any one house. It's the rhythm of them — twenty facades in a row, same height, same stoop, same cornice line — and then, on the second look, how different they all are. One facade is the deep rusty brown the stone was born with. The next is painted cream. The one after that is a dusty pink, and the cornice above it is black as a piano lid. People assume brownstones were always brown. They weren't. The paint colors in New York City brownstones have been argued over, scraped off, layered back on, and reinvented for almost two hundred years, and most of that history is still sitting on the walls, one coat under the next, waiting for someone with a scraper and a little patience.

We paint in these houses every week. Old plaster, old trim, eight or nine paint jobs stacked on a single door frame. You learn a lot about a house from what's under the top coat. This is the story those layers tell.

The Stone That Gave the Color Its Name

Start with the obvious: a brownstone isn't a brown house. It's a brick house wearing a thin skin of brown sandstone — about six inches of it over common brick, carved into doorways, lintels, and cornices — and that skin is where the whole story begins. The stone came mostly from one place. The quarries at Portland, Connecticut, on the Connecticut River, supplied an estimated 80 percent of New York City's brownstone, and at the peak of the trade they employed more than 1,500 men and shipped stone downriver on a fleet of at least 25 boats. Quarrying there goes back to 1690, but the boom hit in the middle of the 1800s, when New York was building row houses by the block. The 1880 federal census counted stone buildings across the city and found that 78.6 percent of them used brownstone, in whole or in part — which is why the word "brownstone" stopped meaning a stone and started meaning a kind of house altogether.

Here's the part most owners never hear: the stone is pink when it's first cut. Fresh out of the quarry, Portland brownstone is a pale, almost salmon pink. It darkens to that familiar rusty brown as it weathers. So the color New York thinks of as "brownstone" is really the color of a stone that's been rained on for a hundred and fifty years. And the stone was cheap, soft enough to carve, and — this mattered more than anyone admits — it hid dirt. The cities of the mid-1800s ran on coal and horses, and the air was full of soot. A brown facade didn't show the grime the way white marble did. The color was practical camouflage before it was a style.

It didn't stay fashionable. The so-called Brown Decades of the mid-19th century gave way, around the turn of the century, to gleaming white limestone and marble, and the brownstone fell out of favor hard. Edith Wharton, who grew up among them, called brownstone the most hideous stone ever quarried. By the early 1900s the Portland quarries were fading — they produced $575,000 worth of stone in 1890 and only $55,949 by 1908 — and a flood in 1936 followed by a hurricane in 1938 finished them off. A small operation reopened in the 1990s for restoration work, then closed for good in 2012. There is no more new Portland brownstone. Every facade you see today is original stone, a patch, or a paint job pretending to be stone.

Before Brownstone: What New York Painted in the 1830s and 1840s

The row house didn't start brown. The earliest New York rowhouses — Greek Revival houses from the 1830s through about 1850, the kind you still find in Brooklyn Heights and the West Village — were usually brick or wood, and their paint followed the fashion of the day: bright white bodies with green shutters. White was the color of a house that wanted to look like a Greek temple. Green was the color of the shutters and the front door. George Washington had famously called the green in his Mount Vernon dining room "grateful to the eye," and the taste stuck for generations.

Then Andrew Jackson Downing published "Cottage Residences" in 1842, and the conversation changed. Downing included what amounted to the first architectural color card in America, and his advice was blunt: paint your house the colors of the landscape around it. Grays and browns, because they matched stone and wood. Red, because it matched brick. White, he argued, was a mistake on a house — it fought the setting instead of sitting in it. The argument landed. Through the 1840s and 1850s, house colors across the Northeast drifted toward the earthy palette Downing championed, and the brown stone coming down the Connecticut River fit that taste exactly. The stone and the paint theory arrived at the same moment, and the city ran with both.

The Italianate Years: When the Facade Became the Paint Job

The Italianate brownstone — the one most people picture, with the high stoop, the arched doorway, the heavy bracketed cornice — flourished from about 1840 to 1870, and it spread through Brooklyn Heights, Cobble Hill, Carroll Gardens, and up into Manhattan almost as fast as builders could put it up. By the late 1840s, nearly all new residential architecture in Manhattan and Brooklyn was faced in brownstone. The style borrowed from the 15th-century Italian palazzo: classical detail, a little grandeur, all of it squeezed onto a 20-foot-wide lot.

But look closely at those facades and you'll see the paint was always part of the architecture. The stone was the body, but the cornice, the window frames, the iron railings, and the front door were painted — and owners have been choosing those colors ever since. Old-timers on brownstone forums still trade notes on what they find under their scrapers: cornices that were dark green, or maroon, or black, or a brown matched close to the stone itself. The rule of thumb that survives is that the cornice was usually painted a close approximation of the stone color, or a dark contrasting tone — black and deep green show up again and again. Nobody painted a cornice white. The whole point was a unified front, a single composition read from the sidewalk, and the paint was what tied the carved stone together.

Inside, the same houses were getting the full treatment. The parlor floor — the raised first floor you reach by climbing the stoop — was the showroom, and it got the best paint in the house.

Inside the Parlor: Victorian Color at Full Volume

If the outside of a brownstone was restrained, the inside, by the 1870s and 1880s, was anything but. This is the part of the story that surprises people who think of Victorian interiors as dark and gloomy. They were dark, sometimes — but they were also saturated, patterned, and deliberately theatrical.

When the Neo-Grec style came into fashion in the 1870s, stenciling, polychrome work, and geometric patterns took over the best rooms. Entry halls, parlors, and dining rooms got the treatment: plaster ceilings divided into geometric shapes, sometimes around an oval center; moldings and trim picked out in a variety of colors; vines, ribbons, and abstract flourishes filling the corners and panels. The ceilings in late 19th-century houses were lighter than the walls, but they were seldom white — that detail comes from the preservation literature, and once you know it, you start seeing it everywhere in old photographs.

The newspaper record is better than any design book. The Brooklyn Daily Eagle, in February 1888, walked through new houses in what is now South Williamsburg and described them room by room: a front bedroom in a brownstone at Lee Avenue and Hewes Street decorated in shades of blue, "with the ceiling frescoed to represent knotwork, in a mellow tone of blue, with a deep frieze" of flowers. At 174 South 9th Street, the rear parlor ceiling was "frescoed to represent the four seasons, and the walls covered with silk plush extended over an ornamental molding." Next door to 512 Bedford Avenue, a house had Lincrusta wainscoting in the hall, side walls "in terra cotta, painted in fine stencil work," and ceilings "exquisitely frescoed in straw color to match." These weren't mansions. They were spec-built row houses, and their ceilings were hand-painted.

It wasn't only the wealthy. An 1895 painted lady in what is now Bed-Stuy — a two-family house without central heating — had a robin's-egg-blue dining room, sugar-pine woodwork faux-painted to resemble oak, gilded rope-pattern picture rails in the parlor, and slate fireplace mantels ornamented with gilded incised decoration and painted to resemble marble. Rental ads in the Eagle bragged about it: a flat at 308 Hicks Street in Brooklyn Heights was advertised in October 1895 with "frescoed ceilings" right alongside the seven rooms, the cabinet mantels, and the dumbwaiter. Painted decoration was a selling point, not a luxury extra.

The materials were humbler than the effects. Designs on plaster were usually done in water-based paints — calcimine and distemper — while oil paints were saved for the woodwork. That split still matters today, because calcimine doesn't hold a modern latex coat without the right prep, and we've seen more than one "simple repaint" turn into a peeling mess when somebody skipped that step.

Faux Finishes and the Painters Who Faked It

A lot of what looked expensive in a 19th-century brownstone wasn't. The front doors, even in fine woods like mahogany, were often faux-grained. Floor cloths were painted to resemble marble. Slate mantels were painted to resemble marble. Pine was painted to resemble oak. The whole decorative-painting trade was built on making cheap materials look dear, and the men who did it best weren't house painters at all — they were sign painters and carriage painters, hired for their steady hands.

The great example sits up the Hudson at Olana, the house Frederic Edwin Church built for himself. Church, a Hudson River School painter, treated his own walls the way he'd treat a canvas: oil paint on both woodwork and plaster, colors mixed under his direction from pigment, oil, and turpentine, applied by sign and carriage painters working to his designs. A detail of one of his intricately painted doors is still the image that opens every history of the subject. And down in Manhattan, the dressing room of Arabella Worsham's townhouse got a hand-painted and stenciled frieze on canvas in 1882 — the kind of work the Metropolitan Museum thought worth keeping when the house came down.

The point for anyone repainting a brownstone today is that the original finishes were rarely a single flat color. A door might be grained. A mantel might be marbled. A ceiling might carry a stencil border in two or three tones. If you strip a piece of trim in one of these houses and find a strange, mottled layer under the white, don't assume it's damage. It might be the best work in the house.

Brownstone Paint Colors: What the Palettes Actually Looked Like

So what did it all look like, in plain color terms? The paint companies have done the homework for us. Sherwin-Williams keeps a "Color Through the Decades" archive, and its 1830s-to-1910s pages read like a tour of the brownstone era: early Victorian shades with names like Gallery Green, Toile Red, Rose Brocade, Patchwork Plum, Eastlake Gold, and Teal Stencil, then late Victorian colors like Queen Anne Lilac, Pewter Tankard, Majolica Green, Crewel Tan, Wickerwork, and Chelsea Mauve. The thread through both lists is contrast — reds paired with greens, golds with purples, rich and intense shades set against each other. The Victorians didn't do pale. They did bold, and then, as the century wore on, slightly more subdued versions of bold.

Benjamin Moore's Williamsburg Collection comes at the same history from the other end: 144 colors, from CW-5 to CW-720, developed with the preservationists at Colonial Williamsburg by examining 18th-century artifacts and re-creating the colors found in early American buildings. Wythe Blue, Capitol White, Bruton White, Tavern Gray — these are the quieter, earlier side of the story, the Federal and Colonial palette that brownstone owners reach for when they want a parlor to feel old without feeling like a museum set. If you want to see how those older whites behave on real pre-war trim, our guide to period-appropriate colors in the Upper East Side Historic District walks through the same idea in an Upper East Side context — same problem, same cream tones, different block.

And the green deserves a sentence of its own. Green paint was everywhere in the 18th and 19th centuries — shutters, doors, trim, whole dining rooms — and the green of the period was often made with arsenic compounds, which people at the time believed kept insects away. The chemistry is long gone from modern paint, thankfully, but the color stuck. A deep green front door on a brownstone still reads as period-correct to anyone who knows the history, and it's still one of the first colors we suggest when a client wants a door with some presence.

How We Know: Reading a Wall Like a Tree Ring

All of this history survives because paint keeps a record. Every coat is a layer, and a trained eye — or a microscope — can read them the way you'd read tree rings. The National Park Service's Preservation Brief 28, the standard reference on painting historic interiors, calls this a paint investigation: specialists take tiny samples, cut cross-sections, and use fluorescent and chemical staining to identify the binders and pigments in each layer. A complete analysis can establish the sequence of alterations in a building, date changes, and identify the exact original color of a surface so it can be matched.

The Brooklyn Museum did exactly this with the Jan Martense Schenck House, a 17th-century Brooklyn farmhouse in its collection. When the museum decided to repaint the house, conservators took paint cross-sections from the oldest surviving siding. Under the museum's own blue topcoat they found many layers of white, then a broken-up green layer, and beneath that, directly on the wood, a red layer. Consulting their curator, they concluded the white layers were the 19th-century scheme, and the red and green were older — so the house went back to deep red, its oldest known color. That's the method in miniature: scrape, look, and let the wall tell you what it was.

We've done the low-tech version of this on a hundred job sites. A razor blade, a bright light, and a corner of trim nobody sees will show you five or six colors in a stack. The bottom one is usually the bravest. The top ones are usually white. That's not a coincidence — it's the whole history of the house, compressed into a sixteenth of an inch.

The Fall and the Comeback

By 1900 the brownstone was out. Limestone and marble were the new status materials, and the brownstone became shorthand for old-fashioned, then for poor. The houses that had been built for the middle class became rooming houses, then SROs, then, in some blocks, near-ruins. The Municipal Art Society notes that New York counts more than 200,000 row houses across the five boroughs — an enormous housing stock — and for much of the 20th century a huge share of it was neglected, carved up, and painted over in whatever was cheapest. The tenement blocks downtown went through their own version of the same story — we traced the tenement-era color palettes of the Lower East Side a few weeks back — and by the time Art Deco arrived, the city's taste had moved on entirely; our Art Deco interior colors guide picks up the story where the brownstone era leaves off.

The turnaround started in the 1960s and 70s, when young buyers priced out of Manhattan began moving into Brooklyn Heights, Cobble Hill, and Park Slope and fixing up the houses they'd bought for almost nothing. Village Preservation's photo archive captures that moment: people sitting on their stoops in the early 1970s, in front of Greek Revival doorways from the 1830s, in a city that was supposed to be finished. It wasn't. The brownstone revival was the beginning of the historic-district movement in New York, and it turned these houses from embarrassments into the most desirable real estate in the city.

Paint came back with the houses. In the 1980s and 90s, decorative paint effects — sponging, ragging, trompe l'oeil — had a full revival, helped along by Jocasta Innes's book "Paint Magic" and the influence of decorator John Fowler. The techniques were old, but the audience was new: owners who wanted their parlors to look like they'd always looked, only better. The modern version of the story is quieter — a Park Slope townhouse renovation finished with Farrow & Ball's Skimming Stone on the facade and Benjamin Moore Black on the trim, the door, the balusters, and the handrails. Same moves the Victorians made: a pale body, a dark trim, a door with presence. The colors changed. The instincts didn't.

What the Landmarks Commission Lets You Paint Today

Here's where the history stops being trivia and starts being paperwork. Most of the great brownstone blocks in Manhattan and Brooklyn sit inside historic districts, which means the Landmarks Preservation Commission has a say in what happens to the outside of your house. The good news is that paint is one of the easier things to get right.

The Commission's own permit guidebook spells it out: repainting a facade or an architectural feature in its existing color is allowed, provided the color was there before the district was designated. A recent permit for a house at 238 Bergen Street in Boerum Hill approved exactly the kind of work we're talking about — resurfacing the brownstone stoop with a brownstone-tinted mortar, and repainting the cornice black. Minor work like that goes through a Permit for Minor Work, a staff-level approval that can move in a matter of weeks. Sandblasting, on the other hand, is banned outright — it destroys the stone — and the Commission prefers repairs in kind, matching stone where the stone is gone, rather than substitute materials.

One quirk owners should know: the color your house wears now might be grandfathered. If a facade was painted pink before the block was landmarked, the Commission will generally let you repaint it pink. The original designation report for your historic district lists the color of every address at the time of designation, and it's worth looking up before you pick a new one. A color that looks wrong to you might be the color the Commission expects you to keep — and a color you love might need a conversation first.

Inside, the rules loosen. Interior work generally doesn't need Landmarks review at all, unless it requires a Department of Buildings permit or affects the exterior. That's why the parlor is where owners get to have their fun, and the facade is where they follow the record.

Choosing Brownstone Paint Colors for Your Home Now

So what do you actually do with all this, if you own one of these houses and the paint is tired? A few things we've learned from doing it.

First, scrape before you choose. A small test patch on a piece of trim or a door edge will show you the original colors in sequence, and the bottom layer is often worth building a scheme around. If you'd rather have it done properly, a paint investigation — the cross-section analysis the Park Service describes — costs less than a single wrong repaint and settles arguments with the co-op board, the landmarks staff, and your own second thoughts.

Second, borrow from the real palettes instead of inventing one. The Sherwin-Williams decades collection and the Benjamin Moore Williamsburg colors exist precisely because someone did the archive work. A parlor in a deep historic green with cream trim, a hallway in a warm stone tone, a front door in near-black or deep green — those combinations aren't guesses. They're the colors these houses wore when they were new, mixed in modern paint that will actually last. We've written about how that kind of period thinking works room by room in our guides to Harlem brownstone interiors and West Village brownstones and small floor plans, and the same logic applies to the landmarked rowhouses across the river too — our friends at Hoboken Painter wrote up what the plaster walls in a Hoboken brownstone are really like, and the bones are the same.

Third, keep the facade honest. Match the stone where the stone shows, pick the cornice color from the record — black and deep green are the safe historic bets — and treat the front door as the one place to be bold. A door can carry a color the facade can't.

And fourth, budget for the prep. Period-correct work on a brownstone costs more than a quick repaint, because the prep is the job: the scraping, the plaster repair, the priming that keeps a new coat from peeling off a century of old ones. If you want a sense of what that scope looks like in a landmarked rowhouse neighborhood, Manhattan Painters just published a breakdown of what West Village apartment painting costs when prep, detail, and access are part of the quote — same building type, same constraints, and the numbers track with what we see on our side of the river. Our own cost calculator will give you a ballpark for the interior side, and a free quote gets you a real number for your rooms.

One last thing. If you live in a brownstone and you're choosing colors, look at the neighbors before you look at a fan deck. The street is the palette. The houses were built as a row, and they read as a row — and the best repaints, the ones that make people slow down on the sidewalk, are the ones that fit the block while still letting one house be itself. The Victorians understood that. The Landmarks Commission understands it. And after two hundred years of paint, the walls themselves have been trying to tell us the same thing.