NYC Painters - Best New York City Interior Painters

Interior Painting & High-End Custom Decorative Painting Services for New York City

(212) 658-1055

Whether you require the painting and decorating of a home, office, store, or even a church, NYC Painters is the perfect choice. We will work around your needs and your times, causing minimum disruption to your home life. We will treat your timetable as a fixed deadline – not just a guideline!

Our success is based on combining experienced, fully qualified residential and commercial decorators and painters, rigorous quality control and flexible hours of working. We use eco-paints with no smell if that is what you need. According to our clients we are one of the best painting and decorating companies in NYC.

We are licensed & fully insured.

Painting Original Plaster Crown Molding in Pre-War Apartments

Painting Original Plaster Crown Molding in Pre-War Apartments

Walk into a pre-war living room on West End Avenue and the first thing your eye catches isn't the wall color. It's the line where the wall meets the ceiling. That plaster crown molding — the curve, the dentils, the little egg-and-dart run over the windows — has been there since the building went up, and it changes the whole room. Paint it well and the room looks finished in a way no furniture can fake. Paint it badly and every flaw is lit up from ten feet below, because molding catches shadow the way flat walls never do.

We've painted miles of the stuff. Pre-war crown molding is the detail that separates a careful job from a fast one, and it's where most repaint jobs in Manhattan either earn their money or quietly waste it. Here's how we approach it, from the first look at the cracks to the last brushstroke.

What you're looking at: plaster crown molding, not wood

First thing to get straight: in a real pre-war apartment, that crown molding is plaster. Not wood, not foam, not the polyurethane lengths from a home center. Plaster was the standard interior finish in American buildings until the 1930s and '40s, and the National Park Service's preservation guidance puts it plainly — plaster was used as the interior surface coating for nearly all buildings of that era, in three coats over lath, and it should be kept and repaired whenever possible.

The ornamental work has its own history. Decorative plaster in America runs from the mid-18th century through the Depression years, moving through Georgian, Federal, Greek Revival, and all the revival styles after them, and the traditional methods of making and installing it came over from Europe and stayed virtually unchanged for two centuries. A plasterer either ran the molding in place — pulling a shaped template along wet plaster at the wall-ceiling joint, pass after pass, until the profile built up — or cast pieces in molds and set them in place. The fancier the building, the deeper the profile. A Rosario Candela building on Park Avenue might carry a cornice a foot deep with dentils and egg-and-dart; a solid middle-class building on West End Avenue gets a clean cove and a bead. Both are the same craft.

The ceiling medallion in the middle of the room is the molding's companion piece. Medallions came to America in the 18th century and peaked in the 19th, and they weren't only decoration — they hid the soot that oil and gas lamps left above the fixture, and gave the chandelier something to hang from. They were usually painted white or cream, pale on purpose, so they wouldn't fight with the heavier color on the walls. When we paint a room with a medallion, we treat it as part of the molding, same paint, same sheen, same care.

Here's why the distinction matters on the job. Wood molding you can sand aggressively, fill with putty, and shoot with a sprayer. Plaster molding you can't. It's brittle. It chips if you lean a ladder into it wrong. The crisp edge that makes a dentil read from across the room disappears under two coats of heavy paint, and it never comes back unless somebody strips the whole run — which nobody wants to pay for. So the whole job bends around one rule: as little paint as the profile needs, and no more.

Why the molding is worth saving

Ask a broker what sells a pre-war apartment and the molding comes up fast. "Many of our clients love pre-war homes for their high ceilings, thick walls, original moldings, and that undeniable sense of character that simply can't be replicated in modern construction," Ben Jacobs, a luxury broker at Douglas Elliman, told 6sqft. Steven Gottlieb, an agent at Coldwell Banker Warburg, put it the same way: "There is a graciousness to the architecture and the layouts, as so many of the apartments boast high ceilings, grand room scale, and details like crown moldings, beams, and elegant hardwood floors."

They're describing the same buildings we work in every week. In New York real estate, "pre-war" generally means buildings put up from the 1880s to the mid-1940s, and the ceiling heights tell you which end of that range you're in — most pre-war ceilings run nine or ten feet, and in the formal buildings they reach eleven or twelve. That height is exactly what makes the molding visible. In a new condo with eight-foot ceilings, crown molding is a strip you barely notice. In a pre-war living room, it's a foot of plaster sculpture running around all four walls at eye level when you're standing on a ladder, and dead center in your sightline the rest of the time.

The buildings prove the point. The pre-war co-op at 740 Park Avenue was designed in the 1920s by Rosario Candela. The Oliver Cromwell, an Emery Roth building, asked just under $6 million this year. Nobody pays that for square footage alone. They pay it for the rooms — and the rooms are the moldings, the medallions, the plaster.

Once original molding is gone, it's gone. A plasterer can take a mold off a surviving run and recast a missing section, and we've seen it done beautifully, but it's slow, skilled, expensive work. Ripping a cracked run out and replacing it with stock wood trim is faster and cheaper, and it reads exactly like what it is: a replacement. If the molding is still there, the smart money keeps it.

Read the damage before you pick up a brush

Every molding job starts the same way for us: lights off, work light held at a shallow angle along the run, and a slow walk around the room. Raking light shows everything — every crack, every old patch, every place a previous painter loaded the brush too heavy and buried a dentil.

Most of what you'll find is hairline cracking, and most hairline cracks are cosmetic. Plaster moves with the building. Settlement cracks run diagonally off door and window corners. The ones that come back every year usually come from the lath behind the plaster: wood swells and shrinks with the seasons, and the National Park Service notes that cracks which keep reappearing with seasonal humidity changes need to be widened and filled properly, not just skimmed over again. A crack you can keep painting over is a crack that was never really repaired.

Then there's the stuff that stops the job. Press the plaster gently on either side of a crack. If it feels solid, you're fine. If it gives, or feels springy, the keys — the little fingers of plaster that squeezed through the lath and hardened on the back — have broken, and that section is hanging on habit. A ceiling that sags or feels soft when you press it isn't a paint problem, it's a plaster problem, and paint won't hold it up. Same with water stains: brown rings on a molding mean a leak above, and until the leak is found and fixed, any repair you make is temporary. We don't paint over active damage. We fix the cause, then the plaster, then we paint.

One more flag: a crack that keeps getting wider, year after year, or a stair-step crack running along a masonry wall. That's the point where we tell the owner to get a structural engineer in before anyone touches a trowel. Nine times out of ten it's nothing. The tenth time, you're glad you asked.

Lead paint decides how the job runs

Here's the part that isn't optional. If your building went up before 1978, the paint on that molding probably contains lead somewhere in its layers. The EPA puts the number at more than 38 million American homes with lead paint from before the residential ban in 1978, and the federal Renovation, Repair and Painting rule covers any paid work that disturbs more than six square feet of painted surface per room inside a pre-1978 home. That work has to be done by an EPA-certified firm using lead-safe practices — containment, no open-flame burning, no dry sanding or dry scraping, HEPA cleanup.

Six square feet sounds like a lot until you do the math on a living room's worth of crown molding. A twelve-foot run of molding with a deep profile, sanded and scraped along its face, gets there fast. So the rule of thumb on our jobs is simple: test first, assume lead until the test says otherwise, and never dry-sand old molding. A certified renovator on the crew, plastic sealing the work area, and a HEPA vacuum aren't upgrades — they're the job. Any painter who tells you lead rules don't apply to "just a little trim work" is a painter you shouldn't hire.

If you're doing this yourself in your own apartment, the federal rule doesn't bind you the way it binds a hired firm. The dust doesn't care. Same precautions, same test kit, same respirator. Lead dust is invisible, and it doesn't stay in the room you made it in.

The landmark question, answered in one paragraph

Owners in historic districts always ask this one, so let's settle it. The Landmarks Preservation Commission got the authority to protect interiors in 1973, and since then it has designated 117 interiors across the five boroughs — 94 of them in Manhattan. But an interior can only be designated if it's customarily open or accessible to the public: Grand Central's concourse, a theater, a hotel lobby. Your living room isn't that, and it never will be. So repainting the crown molding in your apartment doesn't need LPC approval, and nobody from the Commission is coming to check your white. What does need attention is your co-op or condo board's alteration agreement — that's the document that actually governs work inside your apartment, and most boards want to see the scope, the insurance, and the work hours before a crew shows up. We've written about how pre-war co-op boards handle painting approvals before, and the short version is: get the paperwork in first, then paint.

Fixing plaster crown molding so paint has something to hold

Repairs come before paint, always, and in this order:

  • Reattach what's loose. Sound plaster that's pulled away from its lath gets pinned back with plaster washers and screws driven into the framing, then the washers get buried in compound. This is the step that keeps the repair from cracking again in six months.
  • Widen the cracks that keep coming back. A hairline that reopens every winter gets opened with a sharp tool, cleaned out, and filled with setting compound — not spackle, which doesn't bridge movement. The Park Service's own guidance is to widen and fill recurring cracks rather than skim over them.
  • Recast what's missing. If a section of ornament is gone — a run of dentils knocked off by a mover, a chunk of egg-and-dart lost to a leak — a plasterer takes a mold from a surviving section of the same profile and casts a replacement. Done right, you can't find the seam from the floor. Recasting ornament is specialist work, and it's part of what our decorative painters handle on historic interiors.
  • Skim the flat runs. Where the plaster beside the molding is rough or wavy, a thin skim coat levels it so the molding reads against a clean field instead of a lumpy one. We wrote about limewash and plaster walls in historic Manhattan homes and the same logic applies: the flat work has to be flat, or the ornament looks like an afterthought.
  • Let new plaster dry. Fresh plaster needs two to three weeks to dry before paint, then an alkali-resistant primer. Paint too soon and the finish peels in sheets. This is the step impatient jobs skip, and it's the one that costs the most to redo.

A note on caulk: the joint where the molding meets the wall and the joint where it meets the ceiling both get a thin bead of paintable caulk, smoothed with a wet finger, and it has to be fully cured before paint goes on. That clean caulk line is half of what makes the molding look crisp. But caulk is not filler. If the gap is wide enough to need caulk as structure, the molding has moved and needs a plasterer, not a caulk gun.

Picking the white

Nobody thinks choosing white is hard until they're staring at fifty of them on a fan deck in a pre-war living room. The molding is where the choice shows, because it's the brightest surface in the room and it sits right next to the wall color.

Light reflectance value — LRV, the number that says how much light a color bounces back — is the fastest way to sort them. Benjamin Moore's Chantilly Lace OC-65 sits at 90.04, the brightest white in the line, with Simply White OC-117 just behind at 89.52. Cloud White CC-40 comes in at 85.05, warm and soft, and White Dove OC-17 at 83.16, the classic warm white that shows up on trim all over the pre-war stock. Those numbers come from Benjamin Moore's own published values.

What do they mean in the room? Chantilly Lace is the crisp, no-undertone white — it frames a wall color cleanly and it makes a molding's profile pop, but next to a soft, muted wall it can read stark. White Dove is the forgiving one: warm enough to sit comfortably against old plaster and herringbone floors, still clearly white. Cloud White splits the difference. Our default in pre-war apartments is White Dove or Cloud White on the molding, because the rooms already have warmth in the floors and the plaster, and a stark white fights it. In a loftier, more modern-feeling pre-war — say a big open living room in a converted building downtown — Chantilly Lace earns its keep.

Two more decisions. First, keep one white for all the trim in the apartment — molding, baseboards, door casings, window trim. Different whites in different rooms make the place look choppy, and the molding is the first place the mismatch shows. Second, decide whether the ceiling matches the molding. Painting the ceiling the same white as the molding makes the room feel taller and calmer, and it's what we do most of the time. A brighter white on the ceiling than on the molding is fine too. What's not fine is a ceiling darker than the molding — it reads dingy, and it makes the crown look like it's floating.

If the walls are a strong color, the white matters even more. A deep green or navy wall against a warm White Dove molding looks intentional. Against a cold, blue-white molding, the same wall looks like a mistake. If your building sits in a historic district, the period-appropriate interior colors we covered for the Upper East Side historic district are a good starting point for wall colors that sit well with original molding. Sample pots on the actual molding, in the actual light, before you commit. The fan deck lies. The wall doesn't.

The paint that belongs on plaster crown molding

Wall paint on molding is the most common mistake we fix. Flat wall paint on a profile that catches light from three angles looks chalky, marks when you brush past it with a shoulder, and shows every lap mark. Molding wants an enamel — and on old plaster, it wants a waterborne alkyd enamel.

Benjamin Moore's Advance is the one we reach for most. It's a water-based alkyd that goes on smooth and cures to a hard, furniture-like finish, and Benjamin Moore's own trim guidance pairs it with their Fresh Start primer for exactly this kind of work. Sherwin-Williams' Emerald Urethane Trim Enamel is the other pro standard. Both run about $65 to $75 a gallon, and both are worth it — the paint is the cheapest part of a molding job, and the difference between a leveling enamel and a bargain latex is visible from the doorway for years.

Sheen is the other half of the decision. Benjamin Moore recommends semi-gloss for trim and doors, matte or eggshell for walls, and flat for ceilings, and that split exists for a reason. Satin or semi-gloss on the molding gives the profile definition: light slides across the curves instead of dying on them, and the surface wipes clean. Flat on the molding flattens the detail you just paid to preserve. High gloss is the drama option — it looks extraordinary on a deep, crisp profile in a formal room, and it shows every imperfection in the plaster, so the prep has to be perfect. Most of our pre-war jobs land on satin. It reads like the molding always looked, only cleaner.

Prime everything bare. Fresh plaster, patched spots, filler, any place the old paint was scraped back — spot-prime or prime the whole run. Paint over a raw patch without primer and the patch reads as a dull spot through the finish coat, no matter how many coats you put on. One coat of primer, two coats of finish. The can might say one coat covers. On a hundred-year-old profile, two coats is the only way to get the true color.

How we paint it without brush marks

Order matters. Ceiling first, then the molding, then the walls. Benjamin Moore's trim guide says the same thing: start at the top and work down — crown molding, window frames, door frames, baseboards last. Painting the ceiling first means any ceiling paint that lands on the crown gets covered when the crown gets its coats. Painting the molding before the walls means the wall color can be cut up to the molding by hand, clean, without tape.

The brush is a 2-inch angled sash, good nylon-polyester bristles — Purdy or Wooster, not the bargain bin. Dip a third of the bristle into the paint, tap the excess off on the inside of the can, and pull the brush in one long, smooth stroke along the profile. Work in three- or four-foot sections and always brush back into paint that's still wet. The mistake is going back over a section that's started to set — once the paint loses its wet sheen, about ninety seconds in, leave it alone. Rebrushing a drying edge pulls the surface and leaves drag marks that catch the light forever.

Between coats, a light scuff with 220-grit sandpaper knocks down dust nibs and raised grain so the second coat goes on like glass. Wipe the dust off, don't just blow it around. And keep the room's humidity in mind: damp days stretch the drying time and can leave an enamel tacky for days. We'd rather wait for a dry day than explain a tacky finish.

Cutting the wall color up to the molding is hand work, and it's where a good painter earns the fee. No tape on the molding — paint seeps under it on a curved profile and leaves a ragged edge. Load the brush light, put a little paint on the wall just below the molding as a reservoir, and work it up to the edge in one steady pass. It takes a steady hand and a ladder at the right height. That's the job.

What it costs to do it right

Nobody can quote a molding job off a photo, and anyone who tries is guessing. What we can tell you is what drives the number, so you can read a quote and know what you're paying for.

Linear feet is the first driver — a pre-war living room with a deep cornice has more molding, and more profile to paint, than a bedroom with a simple cove. Ceiling height is the second: nine-foot ceilings mean ladder work, eleven-foot ceilings mean scaffolding or a taller setup, and every foot of height adds time. Condition is the third, and it's the one that surprises people: molding that's been painted twenty times, with buried detail and cracked runs, needs stripping, repair, and sometimes recasting before a brush ever touches it. A medallion in the center of the ceiling adds its own line item — it's detail work overhead, and it takes as long as a whole wall of flat trim.

For a sense of how the pieces stack up, our sister company Manhattan Painters breaks down what walls, ceilings, and trim cost on the Upper West Side, room by room. And our own apartment painting cost calculator will give you a starting range for the whole apartment, molding included. The real number comes from someone standing in the room with a light and a ladder, looking at the actual plaster. If a quote for a pre-war apartment doesn't mention the molding at all, ask why — either it's not in the scope, or the painter hasn't looked up.

Keep it, fix it, paint it twice

That molding survived the Depression, a dozen owners, steam heat, and at least five bad paint jobs. It's the best detail in the apartment, and it's the one thing in the room you can't buy new. The work isn't complicated — repair what's loose, test for lead, pick a white that suits the room, prime, and brush two coats of a leveling enamel on with a good brush. The hard part is the patience: letting plaster dry, letting caulk cure, not rebrushing a drying edge, not skipping the second coat because the first one "looks fine."

Do it right and the molding disappears into the room in the best way — you stop noticing it as an object and start feeling it as the reason the room feels finished. That's the whole point. The plaster was there before you, and if the paint job is done properly, it'll be there long after you.

If your pre-war molding needs a look, get a free quote and we'll come stand in the room with a light and tell you what it actually needs.